Nothing says “Be Mine” like a romantic dinner for two. Why fight the crowds in restaurants, spend too much money, wait⊠twiddle your thumbs⊠and wait some more…even with a reservation, when you can make something like this yourself? This is The Organic Kitchen’s ‘Stuffed Chicken Breast served atop roasted asparagus and drizzled with an herbed cream sauce.
(This post contains affiliate links. I may make a commission from sales but your price remains the same.)
The Meal:
This is such a simple meal, but it looks, tastes and feels extravagant! And just to make sure you don’t feel at all intimidated I will walk you through the process step by step!
Step 1: Make the Cutlets:
Simply cut chicken breasts in half, place between plastic or parchment and pound until about 1/4″ thick. Then generously season one side with salt and pepper.
The Stuffing:
Spread the cutlets with soft creamy goat cheese and then sprinkle with freshly chopped spinach.
âŠthen roll, place seam side down and pop in the oven. That’s all there is to it!
While the chicken is baking, prepare the asparagus by brushing with olive oil and seasoning, then place next to the chicken the last ten minutes of baking.
The Cream Sauce:
The cream sauce is easy too! Just cream, lemon juice, some dijon and fresh dill! Just decadent enough to be satisfying while light enough so you still feel like doingâŠother thingsâŠwink, wink.
To Serve:
You can either serve the whole breast atop the grilled asparagus or slice into pin wheels. Then drizzle with cream sauce to your heart’s content!
What to Serve for Dessert:
How about some Raspberry Tarts!(<–recipe)
The Recipe: Stuffed Chicken Breast and Grilled Asparagus
You will need: a rimmed baking sheet (like this) unbleached parchment paper (like this) and a pastry brush (like this). Use a microplane to zest lemon. I love my battery operated pepper mill! It allows me to prep with one hand and leaves the other free to touch chicken without worrying about cross contamination.
A delicious romantic menu. Also delicious served this over white rice.
- 2 chicken breasts, cut in half and pounded into 4 cutlets (see photos above)
- sea salt
- freshly ground pepper
- 8 oz soft goat cheese room temp (so it's soft and spreadable)
- 1 1/2 cups chopped spinach
- 1 clove small clove garlic, peeled and minced
- 1 cup heavy cream
- 1 Tablespoon fresh lemon juice
- 1 Tablespoon Capers
- 1 Teaspoon dijon mustard
- Sea Salt
- Freshly ground pepper
- 2 Tablespoons fresh dill, chopped (plus more for garnish if desired)
- 1 large bunch asparagus
- sea salt
- freshly ground pepper
-
Preheat oven to 400 degrees and place rack in upper third of oven. Cover rimmed baking sheet with parchment paper
-
Make cutlets by cutting breast in half width wise, placing between plastic or parchment paper and pounding with a rolling pin till chicken is about a 1/4 inch thick (see photos).
-
Season one side lightly with sea salt and pepper.
-
Turn seasoned side down and use a spatula to spread soft goat cheese on unseasoned side.
-
If goat cheese does not spread easily, it's ok. The cheese will spread out as it cooks.
-
Top with chopped spinach. Roll up chicken breast and stuffing and place seam side down on parchment covered rimmed cookie sheet.
-
If you can, place all chicken to one side of cookie sheet leaving room to add asparagus the last ten minutes of cooking. Place in oven and cook for 30-35 minutes. (Check at 30 minutes, if cooked through, remove. If chicken breast are really large you may need to cook 5 minutes longer.) While chicken cooks prepare cream sauce and asparagus.
-
Place sauce pan on medium/high heat. Add olive oil and saute garlic for 30 seconds. Add cream, lemon juice, mustard, and capers. Cook, stirring frequently for four minutes. Remove from heat and stir in fresh dill.
-
 Add a few turns of freshly ground pepper and a couple pinches of sea salt. Taste, adjust if needed, set aside.
-
Brush asparagus with olive oil, sprinkle with sea salt and pepper. Add to cookie sheet with chicken the last 10 minutes of cooking or use separate parchment covered cookie sheet.
-
Place asparagus on plate, top with chicken. You can either leave the breast whole or slice into pinwheels so the stuffing can be seen. Drizzle each chicken breast with a 1/4 cup cream sauce, garnish with remaining chopped dill and serve!
MAY I PLEASE ASK A FAVOR?
We small bloggers need all the help we can get. Subscribing and sharing on social media is very appreciated!
This looks amazing – love the combo of spinach and goat cheese. The herb cream sauce just puts it over the edge. Gorgeous!
Thanks Josie! It’s a favorite combo of mine too;)
Looks amazing! Definitely special enough for your Valentine but looks easy enough for any day of the week!
Thanks Terese! Gotta love a meal that’s easy and delicious!
I am not adventurous (yet) in the kitchen, but my family’s tastebuds are even less willing to try new things and accept some changes. What cheese would you suggest as a substitute for the goat cheese?
Thank you!
Hi Julia, good question. Goat cheese is fairly mild and if you don’t mention it’s goat cheese you may not even get any objections. My husband is not a goat cheese fan but he loves this dish! But if you really feel you need a substitute how about trying a full fat ricotta! I think it would taste great, has the same consistency as goat cheese and I bet your family will love it. Let m know if you try it, and how it goes over:)
I’m not a fan of goat cheese, so I substituted ricotta…it was fantastic!! Easy and delicious, great recipe:)
Perfect!
I made the chicken for my husband on Valentine’s Day, which is also his birthday, and it was PHENOMENAL! We both really enjoyed it. I’m making it again for my parents tonight, thanks so much foe sharing your yummy recipes!
Thanks Ramona! I love hearing that.
Whoa, these look yummy!!!!…..can they be made and frozen? Or prepared and frozen, then thawed & baked?
Thanks,
Claudine
Thank you Claudine! They are yummy. I have never frozen them. I am pretty much a fresh is better kind of girl. If you end up doing it let me know how it works out!
Looks so easy to make! I was looking for a similar recipe and came across your blog! Pinned!
Thanks Mira, it is easy!
with the sauce still tastes fine without the capers?
Yes, but I would miss them:)
I’ve just never used capers that’s why I asked đ I’m afraid to buy them and not like them
They are delicious. They are tiny blossoms, if you peel them open you can see the petals. They are a little salty…sort of like a pickle flavor, but because they are so small they just add a little salty sour umph to a recipe. No need to fear!
Is there a substitute for the cream? I made these without the cream sauce (I am dairy free) and they were good, but I think the cream sauce with the capers would have made them awesome! Thanks!
I guess you could try almond milk or coconut milk…but I never have so I can’t promise anything!
Love Love Love this easy recipe!!! This chicken and dill sauce is truly a favorite at my house. Even the pickiest eaters enjoy this meal đ
Thank you!
I am so glad!
I made this the other night for my boyfriend and it was a major success. So easy and so delicious. Thank you!
yay!!! I love hearing that. Thank you.
this is going to be a stupid question but what temperature should the oven be? In Celsius please
Not stupid at all. According to google 400 degrees F is 204 degrees C.
I just made this for my family for Valentines dinner and it was absolutely delicious. Thank you for making me look like I knew what I was doing.
I am so happy to hear that!
I made this recipe for a romantic dinner with my husband… and it was like going out to a really good restaurant. Seriously, dinner was delicious!!! Also the instructions were very clear and it was super easy. Greetings from Chile!
Thanks Carolina! I am so glad you liked it. Your comment made my day!
=)
Would using white Asparagus precooked from the jar be ok?
I have never used it so I really don’t know. Give it a shot and see what you think!
Just made this for Valentine’s day. It was amazing and my wife and I devoured it. Thanks for a wonderful recipe I’ll make often!
Awesome! Thank you so much for letting me know you loved it!
Do you have nutritional information for this recipe?
I do not. But I believe there are apps you can use for that info if you are interested in finding out:)
Just this for dinner and it was delicious! I didnât have capers but I want to try it with them next time. I also added mushrooms and rice with it and it worked really well with the sauce. Will definitely make this again!
Sounds delicious! So glad you liked it!
I do one similar with sun dried tomatoes mixed into the goat cheese filling, I love this recipe!!
So funny. I am working on one like that right now:)
Oh it’s just SO pretty! And easy too! I can’t wait to make it!
So fancy and impressive! đ
I am a fancy girl đ
Made this for a Valentine’s Day dinner with my wife and daughter. Ran low on the zest and added a little juice, then reseasoned the sauce to even out the flavor. Also, couldn’t find asparagus – first time ever not seeing it. Replaced the asparagus with Yukon Gold mashed potatoes. The dish was a little heavier, but everything fit perfectly together. Great recipe.
Thank you Phillip! I am so glad you liked it!
I love the step-by-step photos and the chicken looks so creamy delicious!
Thanks ChihYu!
Super instructions make this dish very do-able!
Looks like a delightful decadent oh so tasty dish for a special occasion!! anytiime!
Thanks Carol!
This was SOO good! And fairly easy to make, i will 100% make it again!
Thanks Renee! I love it when people actually make it and come back to tell me about it!
you think you could correct the recipe card title to say “Goat Cheese” Stuffed etc.. instead of “goat stuffed” or say Capriol? Because that’s really disturbing. How would one get the goat to fit inside of the chicken?
Oh goodness, thanks for pointing out that omission! Fixed!
I can’t believe all the good reviews for this recipe. I followed it exactly last night, but 35 minutes was way too long. The chicken was overcooked & very dry. đ The internal temp was 180° :O. PLEASE change that part of recipe. I took them out after 32 min but should have taken them out after 25 min. The asparagus was good! But I prob won’t make this again.
Hi Kathy. Sorry about that. Let’s see if I can get to the bottom of this! My first thought (because I have made this recipe successfully many times, although not recently) was that perhaps your oven needs calibrating. Maybe it cooks hotter than mine, even when set at the same temp. That said, the oven I was cooking in when I posted that recipe had not been calibrated in years. I am on vacation right now, but when I get home I will make this recipe again in my brand new oven that was just calibrated, and see if the timing needs to be changed. Although since I get such nice comments from other readers that have made the recipe, I am still thinking that might not be it,I am certainly willing to experiment and if the recipe needs adjusting, I will certainly adjust! I will keep you posted.
Came out great. Used risotto as a carb, and acorn squash as a side, ran out of asparagus… used next fresh item i had… simple quick & easy to prep .. will share recipe with friends !
Will be making this for my fiancĂ©’s birthday!
What is the measurement of capers that should be used (it just says 1 capers)?
Also, Is there an alternative to dill that can be used for this recipe?
Hi. I love this recipe. I am wondering if the cream sauce recipe has changed. I am remembering it differently and it doesnât quite taste the same. Would you be able to post the old cream sauce ingredients/measurements.
Hi Carly, I did update it as I felt the sauce needed a little flavor boost. If you prefer it the old way, just leave out the garlic, lemon and dijon. Have a great day!
Wow.. It is looking to so tasty.